Opting for a truly harmonised scope in the RoHS Directive securing legal certainty and predictability for EEE producers

Published: 15 September 2010

Policies & Issues: Environment

The RoHS recast proposal claims to simplify existing legislation and to avoid unnecessary bureaucracy and administrative costs in line with Better Regulation principles of the EU. However, the RoHS recast proposal in our view fails to realise this objective, in particular since it would create legal uncertainty and worsen the current situation in terms of predictability for producers of electric and electronic equipment.

Therefore, Orgalime’s fundamental request to regulators is to ensure an EU legislation that is workable and enforceable in practice, securing legal certainty and predictability for European industries by supporting the following main proposals:

• Carrying out a representative impact assessment at EU level for any substantial change to the existing directive, such as for the far-reaching proposals for an open scope or new substance restrictions before the adoption of the recast Directive.

• Opting for a truly harmonised scope in the RoHS Directive itself that improves the current situation in terms of legal certainty and predictability for producers of electric and electronic equipment – an open scope does not contribute to clarifying remaining interpretation issues under the existing directive but introduces more questions than answers

• In any case, introducing a concise but comprehensive set of scope exclusions. In our position paper: Main priorities and proposals for further proceedings on RoHS recast of 19 July 2010, we explain the necessity for specific exclusions from the scope. We want to stress that it is of utmost importance that the generic definition provided will not be changed during negotiations processes.

Related Position Papers

Environment: Orgalim Position Paper on the draft French Decree on consumer information for waste-generating products [21 December 2021]

Environment: Joint industry position paper on the concept of Essential Use [3 November 2021]

Environment: Orgalim comments on the draft French Decree on the minimum proportion of reused packaging [28 October 2021]

Environment: Financing key enablers of the green transition: Orgalim position on the EU taxonomy for sustainable activities [6 October 2021]

Environment: Orgalim response to the consultation by the Platform on Sustainable Finance on EU taxonomy [5 October 2021]

Environment: Joint statement on the need for a transition period for the implementation of the Batteries Regulation [28 July 2021]

Environment: Orgalim input to the European Commission consultation on the Revision of the Urban Waste Water Treatment Directive [20 July 2021]

Environment: Orgalim position on the Sustainable Products Initiative [8 June 2021]

Environment: Orgalim position on draft reporting rules for companies under the EU Taxonomy Regulation [2 June 2021]